New Yorkers lukewarm on National Guard deployment to deter subway crime
Some commuters told the BBC it was a good idea. Others expressed concern it might lead to profiling.
New Yorkers' Reaction to National Guard Deployment in Subway
New York City subway riders have expressed mixed reactions to Governor Kathy Hochul's decision to deploy National Guard troops to guard the system. Some commuters view the deployment as a positive step to address the rising crime rates, while others have concerns about potential racial profiling.
Governor Hochul's Rationale for the Deployment
Governor Hochul stated that the deployment of National Guard troops aims to "rid our subways of people who commit crimes and protect all New Yorkers." She cited a series of violent assaults, including three homicides since January, as the motivation behind the decision.
Crime Rates in New York's Transit System
The overall picture of crime in New York's transit system is complex. While overall crime fell by about 3% in 2023 compared to 2022, major crimes have increased by 13% so far this year.
National Guard's Role in Transportation Security
The National Guard already patrols major transportation hubs like the Port Authority terminal and Grand Central Station as part of a program launched after the September 11, 2001 attacks. Governor Hochul's plan assigns an additional mission to 750 guardsmen to monitor major entry points to the subway. Another 250 personnel, including state troopers and transit police, are also part of the security reinforcement.
Public Opinion on the National Guard Deployment
Opinions among subway commuters vary. Some individuals welcome the presence of the National Guard, expressing concerns about crime and the presence of "crazy people" in the streets. Others, however, are not thrilled about the deployment, with one commuter stating that they prefer the police to handle security matters. Some critics argue that the plan may not address the core causes of subway disturbances and could raise constitutional issues.
Concerns about Racial Profiling and Policing Practices
Police reform advocates have raised concerns about the National Guard's deployment and the potential for racial profiling. The announcement that the National Guard would search bags carried by subway riders has drawn comparisons to the controversial policing practice known as stop and frisk, which was found to disproportionately target minorities. Some individuals, particularly people of color, express reservations about being stopped and searched, emphasizing the diverse cultural makeup of New York City.
In conclusion, the deployment of National Guard troops in the New York City subway system has elicited mixed reactions among commuters. While some view it as a necessary measure to address rising crime rates, others have concerns about racial profiling and the potential impact on civil liberties. The overall goal is to enhance security and protect subway riders, but the effectiveness and long-term implications of this deployment remain to be seen